Standards Harmonization and Recommended Standards
The advancement of interoperable electronic health records in Minnesota depends on the capability of the various health information systems in Minnesota to exchange data seamlessly. Standards are a critical ingredient of this interoperability. Because the health care domain has many standards (~2100) to choose from, there needs to be a process for standardizing the standards. By standards harmonization and utilization of approved standards, the various information systems and software applications will have the ability to work together. For progress on interoperable electronic health records in Minnesota, it is critical to promote standards. Minnesota e-Health must keep track of activities and progress on standards at the national level.
The process of harmonization of standards is headed at the national level by the Health Information Technology Standards Panel (HITSP). The objective of HITSP is to achieve widely accepted and readily-implemented consensus-based standards that will enable and support widespread interoperability among healthcare software applications, as they will interact in a local, regional and national health information network for the United States. HITSP functions as a cooperative partnership between the public and private sectors, operating through a neutral and inclusive governance model with participation by experts from across the health care IT community.
An overview of the standards selection and approval process at HITSP:
- A particular scenario for harmonization of standards is chosen based on requests to HITSP and priorities of the American Health Information Community (AHIC).
- Description of this scenario is a “Use Case” which provides details on the interactions between the end user or another system to achieve a specific business goal.
- An agreed upon standards taxonomy is used to organize standards that support each major Use Case event and Tier 1 and Tier 2 Harmonization Readiness Criteria are applied to select standards for inclusion in the Interoperability specifications.
- Standards harmonized for a particular Use Case are presented as recommendations to the American Health Information Community (AHIC).
- AHIC approved standards need to be accepted by the U.S. Department of Health and Human Services (HHS) Secretary.
- These standards would be tested and implemented for a period of time with a possible recognition of the standards after that time frame.
The following table presents details of Use Cases, recommended standards, interoperability specifications and requirements, design and standards selection for selected scenarios.
Printer friendly version with full links (pdf 116Kb/9 pgs)
Use Case |
Use Case Description |
HITSP Harmonization Status |
HITSP Requirements, Design and Standards Selection |
HITSP Interoperability Specifications |
Recommended Standards |
Approval by AHIC |
Secretary of DHHS • Acceptance of Standards • Recognition of Standards |
2006 Use Cases | |||||||
Consumer Empowerment
• Registration • Medication History |
Harmonized Use Case March 19, 2006 (pdf 259Kb/26 pgs) |
Completed |
Version 2.0 (pdf 765Kb/26 pgs) |
October 31, 2006 (pdf 16Kb/1 pg) |
Approved |
Accepted January 23, 2007
|
|
Electronic Health Records (EHR)
• Laboratory Results Reporting |
Harmonized Use Case March 19, 2006 (pdf 269Kb/30 pgs) |
Completed |
Version 2.0 (pdf 765Kb/26 pgs) |
October 31, 2006 (pdf 11Kb/1 pg) |
Approved |
Accepted January 23, 2007
|
|
Biosurveillance
• Visit
• Utilization • Clinical Data • Lab and Radiology |
Harmonized Use Case March 19, 2006 (pdf 208Kb/20 pgs) |
Completed |
Version 2.0 (pdf 765Kb/26 pgs) |
October 31, 2006 (pdf 14Kb/2 pgs) |
Approved |
Accepted January 23, 2007
|
|
Privacy and Security Consumer Empowerment
• Registration • Medication History Electronic Health Records (EHR)
• Laboratory Results Reporting Biosurveillance
• Visit
• Utilization • Clinical Data • Lab and Radiology |
Version 1.0 Security and Privacy RDSS
April 13, 2007 (pdf 1917Kb/128 pgs) Approved by the panel on October 15, 2007 |
||||||
2006 Use Cases Updates Consumer Empowerment
• Registration • Medication History Electronic Health Records (EHR)
• Laboratory Results Reporting Biosurveillance
• Visit
• Utilization • Clinical Data • Lab and Radiology |
Being updated to reference the new security & privacy constructs & will be released as v3.0
|
||||||
2007 Use Cases | |||||||
Emergency Responder Electronic Health Record
• On-site Care • Emergency Care • Definitive Care • Provider Authentication and Authorization |
Detailed Use Case December 20, 2006 (pdf 377Kb/43 pgs) |
In process |
• Review Copy of IS constructs (v1.0) released for public comment & inspection testing on Sept 17, 2007 • Scheduled for approval by the Panel on Dec 13, 2007 |
||||
Privacy and Security Emergency Responder Electronic Health Record |
Version 1.0 Security and Privacy RDSS May 16, 2007 (pdf 984Kb/59 pgs) |
||||||
Consumer - Empowerment
Consumer Access to Clinical Information • Access to Clinical Data • Provider Permissions • PHR Transfer |
Detailed Use Case June 18, 2007 |
In process |
• Review Copy of IS constructs (v1.0) released for public comment & inspection testing on Sept 17, 2007 • Scheduled for approval by the Panel on Dec 13, 2007 |
||||
Medication Management
• Medication Reconciliation • Ambulatory Prescriptions • Contra-indications |
Detailed Use Case June 18, 2007 |
In process |
Version 1.0 released for public comment on Sept. 17, 2007 |
IS constructs scheduled for panel approval on March 27, 2008 |
|||
Quality
• Hospital Measurement and Reporting • Clinician Measurement and Reporting • Feedback to Clinicians |
Draft Detailed Use Case June 18, 2007 (pdf 391Kb/44 pgs) |
In process |
• Review Copy of IS constructs (v1.0) released for public comment & inspection testing on Sept 17, 2007 • Scheduled for approval by the Panel on Dec 13, 2007 |
||||
2008 Use Cases | |||||||
Remote Monitoring
• Remote Monitoring of Vital Signs & Labs (Glucose) |
Prototype Use Case August 31, 2007 |
||||||
Remote Consultation
• Structured email • Reminders • On-line Consultation |
Prototype Use Case August 31, 2007 |
||||||
Personalized Healthcare
• Laboratory • Genetic/Genomic Data • Family Medical History |
Prototype Use Case August 31, 2007 |
||||||
Consultation and Transfers of Care
• Referrals • Problem Lists • Transfer of Care |
Prototype Use Case August 31, 2007 |
||||||
Public Health Case Reporting
• Case Reporting • Bidirectional Communication • Labs • Adverse Events |
Prototype Use Case August 31, 2007 |
||||||
Immunizations & Response Management
• Resource Identification • Vaccine • EHR data |
Prototype Use Case August 31, 2007 |
||||||
AHIC Priorities and Use Case Roadmap 2009 and Beyond |
||
CE 3.0 Administrative features CE 3.1 Appointment scheduling CE 3.2 Demographic profile CE 3.3 Editing account profile CE 3.4 Insurance eligibility & claims CE 3.5 Financial recordkeeping & management CE 4.0 Reminders (examples) CE 4.1 Annual check-ups CE 4.2 Cancer screening—mammograms CE 4.3 Cancer screening—colonoscopies CE 4.4 Immunizations CE 6.0 Summaries of healthcare encounters CE 6.1 Dates of services CE 6.3 Procedure codes CE 7.0 Educational information CE 7.1 Evidence based health information CE 8.0 Decision support CE 8.1 Shared decision making CE 8.2 Communications preferences CE 9.0 Patient health outcomes CE 9.1 Adverse events CE 9.2 Medical errors CE 9.3 Patient reported health outcomes |
CC 3.0 Glucose monitoring CC 4.0 Spirometery CC 5.0 Anticoagulation CC 7.0 Fall/motion monitoring CC 11.0 Lesion assessment CC 12.0 Remote monitoring for chronic conditions CC 13.0 HIT use in specific populations CC 15.0 Product and services certification CC 16.1 State licensure constraints CC 18.0 Patient identification for authorization and authentication ----------------------------
EHR 5.0 Clinical/encounter notes EHR 6.0 Anatomic pathology results EHR 8.0 Radiology reports EHR 12.0 Machine readable and interoperable EHR 12.1 Encounter notes EHR 12.2 Radiology reports EHR 12.3 Lab results |
Q 3.1 Clinical decision support Q 5.0 Clinical decision support Q 6.0 Expanded inpatient quality measures Q 7.0 Expanded ambulatory quality measures ----------------------------
BIO 1.2 Clinical symptomology BIO 1.3 Integration with EHRs BIO 1.4 Health alerting (HA)/email alerts BIO 2.1 Collaborative discussions BIO 2.2 Web pages BIO 3.2 Chemoprophylaxis BIO 3.3 Treatment BIO 3.4 Isolation/quarantine BIO 3.6.2 Disease registry BIO 4.0 Adverse event reporting BIO 4.1 Devices, drugs, biologic BIO 5.0 Nosocomial infections BIO 5.1 Medication errors BIO 5.1.1 Ordering/ prescribing/ dispensing BIO 5.1.2 Drug-drug, drug-allergy interaction decision support BIO 5.1.3 Linkage to FDA structured product labeling database results BIO 10.0 Public health information network (PHIN) can be leveraged BIO 14.0 National notifiable disease conditions have been identified |
AHIC 1.0 Labs, medications, allergies, immunizations AHIC 2.0 Secure messaging/online consultation AHIC 3.0 Bi-directional communications AHIC 4.0 Adverse event reporting AHIC 5.0 Case reporting AHIC 6.0 Clinical decision support systems AHIC 7.0 Identification / authentication AHIC 8.0 Problem lists AHIC 9.0 Clinical encounter notes AHIC 10.0 Family history / social factors AHIC 11.0 Vitals signs AHIC 12.0 Population health / conditions AHIC 13.0 Minimum data set AHIC 14.0 Confidentiality, privacy, & security of patient data AHIC 15.0 Data access / data control AHIC 16.0 Data aggregation AHIC 17.0 Infrastructure areas missing AHIC 17.1 Security, network, repositories AHIC 18.0 Vital measurements AHIC19.0 Text documents AHIC 21.0 Health literacy (multilingual support) AHIC 23.0 Advance directive / living wills AHIC 24.0 Social/family history AHIC 26.0 Medication history |
AHIC 27.0 E-prescribing AHIC 28.0 Standardization of device interfaces AHIC 29.0 Care plans / clinical flow sheets AHIC 30.0 Provider list AHIC 31.0 Adverse events AHIC 32.0 Nosocomial infections AHIC 33.0 Clinical data storage for surveillance AHIC 34.0 Case reporting AHIC 35.0 Bi-directional communications AHIC 36.0 Lab results AHIC 37.0 Anatomic pathology results AHIC 38.0 Radiology reports AHIC 39.0 Social history AHIC 40.0 Procedure reports AHIC 41.0 Medications AHIC 43.0 Dental AHIC 44.0 Workflow integration AHIC 45.0 Int’l public health collaboration AHIC 46.0 Legal liability & regulatory barriers AHIC 47.0 Consumer consent |
CCHIT 1.0 Patient safety CCHIT 2.0 Transfer of care ----------------------------
HITSP 1.1.4 Text reports HITSP 1.1.5 Numeric results HITSP 1.1.7 Images HITSP 1.2 HIPAA covered entities HITSP 1.2.1 X12 Claims attachment HITSP 2.0 Secondary uses of data HITSP 2.1 Clinical research HITSP 2.2 Clinical trials HITSP 2.3 Population health HITSP 3.0 Quality / control measurements HITSP 3.1 Consistency across uses HITSP 4.0 Clinical device data HITSP 4.1 Glucometers HITSP 4.2 Monitors HITSP 4.2 Smart pump HITSP 5.0 Cross use case work on security (standards) HITSP 5.3 Authentication models to support chain of trust data exchanges |


